The Prisoner of Azkaban, Chapter 5: Chocolate Is the Cure for Everything

Oh, you guys. YOU GUYS. My love for this chapter almost has no words. Notice I said almost, because I’m about to sling a bunch of words at you that are all about my love for this chapter. The reason I love it so much comes in the form of a certain scruffy, unassuming new Defense Against the Dark Arts professor. Read on!


We begin with breakfast at the Leaky Cauldron and preparations for the journey to Hogwarts (Hogwarts, Hogwarts, Hoggy Warty Hogwarts YAY I’M SO EXCITED). Before the kids board the train for another year at my favorite magical locale, Arthur Weasley takes Harry aside to tell him that Sirius Black escaped Azkaban for the sole purpose of hunting Harry down, which Harry admits he already knows because of eavesdropping. Arthur then very ominously warns Harry not to go looking for Black. Harry doesn’t understand why Arthur thinks he would actively look for someone who wants to kill him. Obviously, Arthur knows Harry better than Harry knows himself.

On the train, the Trio go in search of an empty compartment and find all of them full except for the one at the very end. I’ll let Rowling introduce you to its sole occupant:

The stranger was wearing an extremely shabby set of wizard’s robes that had been darned in several places. He looked ill and exhausted. Though quite young, his light brown hair was flecked with grey.

…and he’s fast asleep. Hermione, ever the observant one, points out that his luggage reads Professor R. J. Lupin, so they have a name and an occupation to attach to the mysterious stranger. Hermione also points out that the Defense Against the Dark Arts position is the only one that’s vacant. DUN DUN DUNNN. It’s time to legitimately start worrying about this dude, considering the position’s previous two occupants.

This is how I imagined Lupin. 😉

Harry tells Ron and Hermione about Sirius Black, and the trio is reaching their freak-out boiling point when Harry’s Sneakoscope suddenly goes off. Ron hides it in a pair of Uncle Vernon’s old socks and sticks it in Harry’s trunk, and not much happens beyond that, but I think it’s safe to say the Sneakoscope is one of Rowling’s important little clues. At this point, it would be natural to suspect that Lupin is untrustworthy, and that was probably Rowling’s intent, but the kids aren’t concerned since they think the Sneakoscope is malfunctioning. Which is actually weird because you’d think they’d be overreacting like they do about everything else. For once, they decide to give something the benefit of the doubt.

The conversation turns to Hogsmeade, which rivals Hogwarts for my favorite magical locale. As much as I love Hogwarts, reading about Hogsmeade for the first time was a fantastic revelation. The realization that the kids weren’t all alone in a giant castle out in the Scottish highlands, that there was an entire wizarding village next to them, opened up a whole new realm of magical excitement. Hogsmeade seemed filled with possibilities and, more importantly, sweets!

Hermione goes on about the history of Hogsmeade, which is actually pretty interesting, while Ron just keeps listing off sweets:

Pepper Imps — they make you smoke at the mouth — and great fat Chocoballs full of strawberry mousse and clotted cream, and really excellent sugar quills, which you can suck in class and just look like you’re thinking what to write next — and massive sherbet balls that make you levitate a few inches off the ground while you’re sucking them.

I would kill for one of those Chocoballs…

Next, Harry is a buzzkill. He tells Ron and Hermione that he can’t go to Hogsmeade because the Dursleys didn’t sign his release form. Cue my heart shattering because if Harry can’t go, then it means I can’t go. All of a sudden this forced perspective thing really sucks.

The food cart comes around, and the kids are settled in while Professor Lupin sleeps, and it’s all very cozy and familiar until the train suddenly stops. The lights go out, and there’s lots of humorous fumbling around as Neville and Ginny make their way to the Trio’s compartment and everybody bumps into each other and almost sits on each other. Out of the darkness, an unfamiliar voice snaps, “Quiet!” and Lupin conjures fire in his hand, which is the first sign that he’s a badass. He doesn’t even need a wand.

We can’t start a new school year without something to put Harry out of sorts, but this year it’s serious business. The compartment door slides open and a literal nightmare steps through.

Happy Halloween!

Happy Halloween!

This is where we’re introduced to the lovely creatures known as dementors. This school year really starts off with no holds barred in the realm of things that could potentially fuck Harry’s world up. The dementor is described as a tall, black-robed figure with slimy dead hands. Harry feels intense cold and a sensation of being dragged downward. He hears someone screaming, and then he passes out.

When Harry comes to, Lupin officially transitions from a character we should be wary of to a character who gives the kids chocolate as medicine. That’s right, Lupin knows: chocolate is the answer to everything. The other kids talk about feeling cold and hopeless, but Harry is embarrassed because he’s the only one who fainted. Harry’s special, you guys! Didn’t you know? We find out later that there’s a reason for his severe reaction, but I won’t get into that now. Hermione recounts the events that followed Harry’s fainting, and we get our first mention of a Patronus, although we don’t have a name for it yet. Hermione describes it as a silvery substance that emitted from Lupin’s wand to dispel the dementor.

One thing that struck me during this re-read is how layered Lupin already is in this early chapter. Within the space of a few pages, we know that he’s young yet worn down and ill, suggesting Hogwarts might be a sort of refuge for him; he’s suspicious yet kind; and he’s a competent wizard who is capable of protecting his students. Once again, Rowling demonstrates her aptitude for establishing interesting characters without revealing too much right away.

The lack of an apostrophe on this kills me, but I love it nonetheless.

When we arrive at Hogwarts, Draco is his usual jerk-face self, laughing at Harry for fainting, but Lupin intervenes. McGonagall takes Harry aside and seems overly concerned for his well-being after the dementor situation. Madame Pomfrey is there too, and she’s got nothin’ but approval for Lupin’s swift administration of chocolate. Important to note is that McGonagall also pulls Hermione aside to discuss her schedule, which is going to be a pretty huge deal later on. We learn that Dumbledore has stationed the hellish dementors outside the castle to protect from the possibility of Sirius Black attempting to breach Hogwarts, but we still don’t know why one drifted into Harry’s train compartment. What we do know is that they serve as guards at Azkaban, draining hope from all of the criminals who are imprisoned there… and now they’re at Hogwarts. Yikes.

Harry climbed the spiral stair with no thought in his head except how glad he was to be back. They reached their familiar, circular dormitory with its five four-poster beds, and Harry, looking around, felt he was home at last.

Me too, Harry. Me too.

A few additional thoughts:

  • This chapter is important in that it sets up so many things for later events in the books. The Sneakoscope, Lupin’s strange illness, Hermione’s meeting with McGonagall, Hogsmeade and the Shrieking Shack, the dementors… Without this chapter, the rest of the book practically wouldn’t exist.
  • I read an interview once wherein Rowling said she wrote the dementors as a response to the depression she felt before receiving her book deal. I think the idea of dementors representing depression is interesting, and it says so much about how writing—and reading—can help a person cope. I also enjoy the parallel between dementors and the Patronus—how repelling a dementor, which represents darkness and negativity, involves conjuring your own personal representation of light and positivity. It sounds cheesy, but perhaps Rowling wanted to illustrate that overcoming depression involves finding happiness from within. The ability to use magic to essentially dispel sadness and despair is one of the many things that makes the wizarding world so appealing.
  • I’m bringing this discussion back: I’d want my Patronus to be a bird of prey, like a falcon or a hawk. How about you?
Tagged , , ,

36 thoughts on “The Prisoner of Azkaban, Chapter 5: Chocolate Is the Cure for Everything

  1. Kevin O'Shea says:

    I have a LOT of Arthur Weasley feels and I really hope I’ll be able to get to them in one of my chapters soon.

    My Patronus, as KROGAN are right out, would be the Capybara, King of Rodents.

    • Alyssa says:

      I’m very excited to read about your Arthur Weasley feels. That sentence sounds weird, but hopefully you know what I mean.

      It’s too bad krogan exist in a different universe because that would make for an impressive patronus.

      • Kevin O'Shea says:


        The short form is, there’s a lot of comparison between Harry’s blood relations and the Weasleys. And a lot of it is really subtle. I’m not going to be able to work it into my first Goblet post, but I’m really going to try for the second.

  2. Gretchen Alice says:

    Um…I am 100% on board with that picture of Ewan McGregor as Lupin. Dang.

    The part with Hermione figuring out Lupin’s name made me want a Hermione/Sherlock crossover where they solve mysteries together. They get help from Ron and Watson, who mostly hang back and wear cozy sweaters and act impressed.

  3. Ashley says:

    I second being on board with Ewan McGregor as Lupin. Yum,

    I really like what Rowling did with Harry in this chapter (or rather, what she does with his reaction to what happens in this chapter). He’s worried about not being like everyone else, but in a bad way, like he’s deficient, which is something he’s not used to. Not brave enough, not strong enough, more afraid. It’s such a teenage boy thing to be worried about.

    I have no idea what my Patronus would be. Probably something dumb like a rabbit. I wish they would do a Patronus quiz on Pottermore.

    • Jennie says:

      Isn’t Luna’s Patronus a rabbit? Therefore rabbits aren’t dumb!

      I’m with you, though, I need a quiz to tell me these things. Is it automatically your favorite animal? Because in that case it would be an otter. Or a penguin. But I don’t think it works that way.

    • Lindsay says:

      HAVE YOU NOT READ BABBITY RABBITY. Rabbits are pretty freaking awesome apparently.

      • Ashley says:

        I had a friend who kept rabbits, and they were dicks. Maybe she just had shitty rabbits, but I hold grudges apparently.

        • Dan says:

          When I was a kid, my neighbor had a rabbit and I would watch it when they went on vacation. The little bastard would bite and scratch me every time I tried to feed him, fill his water bottle, or clean out his little rabbit poop. Rabbits are dicks.

        • Lindsay says:

          Actually rabbits are total dicks.

          • Kevin O'Shea says:

            My dad has to constantly scare them out of his garden. They are massive dicks.

          • Jen says:

            So, your dad is basically Mr. McGregor, chasing Peter around?

            My cousin’s pet bunny was probably the least dickish rabbit ever, but I’d still rather have a cat or dog.

          • Kevin O'Shea says:

            Between the rabbits and the squirrels, half his vegetables every year are either gone or worthless. They even dug up all the bamboo he tried to grow once, from a pot on the patio table – probably in protest because they couldn’t eat it.

          • Jen says:

            Yikes! No insult meant, btw. Peter was a total dick.

  4. Jennie says:

    Yeah, nothing against David Thewlis (I actually really like him as Lupin) but Ewan McGregor has my heart forever.

    It’s interesting that the wizard form of prison and punishment involves, like, leaching away all of your hope and eventually your life. I mean, do you get sent to Azkaban for misdemeanors or do you only go there if you do something truly heinous? Is there a less-dementory prison for first time offenders? And what about juvey? Do baby dementors guard kid prison?

    • Alyssa says:

      Oh wow, I shudder at the thought of baby dementors! That’s just…wrong.

      Good questions, though. There has to be some form of lesser punishment for less severe crimes because, I mean, having your happiness and life force sucked out is a pretty harsh sentence.

  5. Prite says:

    I’m so happy to know that Patronus charms can indeed take forms as small as a ladybug and as large as a wooly mammoth! It was something I was wondering about. There had better be one wizard/archaeologist somewhere in the world who, if they were to cast a Patronus charm, would find that theirs is a brachiosaurus. Like, they understand how it lived, what its behavior patterns are, and what do you know? It’s very similar to them on a deep level, or something. It’s noted that extinct creature Patronuses are very rare, but rarer things have happened!

    If my Patronus were based on my favorite animal, it’d be a pangolin, because those things are awesome. But I can’t say objectively what animal would best represent me if it were more like THAT.

    This chapter really is great, though. It was the train scene that made this book my favorite in the series the first time ’round because, as you noted, it does such an excellent job of setting things up without giving them away, and I thought it was the most exciting before-school chapter of all. It really caused me to continue to be excited about the rest of it. I tend to think now that the plot became pretty cluttered toward the end, but It never did seem to bother me then.

    • Alyssa says:

      I have to admit, I’d never heard of a pangolin until now, but I think I’m obsessed. They’re cute and weird and scaly all at once! And they can curl up into an armored ball! That’s amazing on so many levels.

      • Prite says:

        Aaaaah I know! T_T They’re like if an anteater and an armadillo and a pinecone all had a baby together, and there are ones that live in trees and ones that burrow, and also they are just the best animals. It would be super nice if they enjoyed a little more popularity!

  6. Dan says:

    LUPIN! My favorite Hogwarts professor. Whenever I read this chapter, I picture the episode of The Simpsons when Bart is lost and alone in France and he meets a friendly policeman who, unable to understand what Bart is saying, simply offers him a piece of chocolate. Because CHOCOLATE IS THE CURE FOR EVERYTHING!

    My Patronus would either be some kind of large, loping dog or a grizzly bear.

  7. My patronus is definitely a lioness. Rawr.

  8. Valerie Anne says:

    I also wish there was a Patronus quiz on Pottermore, because I have no idea. Maybe a red panda? Those are cute. Possibly a monkey. Those always make me pretty happy.

    • Dan says:

      It does seem strange that there isn’t one. I mean, there are two things every Potter fan wants to know: their House and their Patronus. Maybe with Order of the Phoenix

      • Alyssa says:

        I really want a Patronus quiz now. Creating a quiz like that could get pretty crazy, though, considering a person’s Patronus could be anything. There would have to be a lot of possible outcomes.

  9. plaunat says:

    It was decided by my friends at quidditch soc that my patronus is a guinea pig. It may seem small and weak but I challenge anyone to still feel depressed after watching dementors scurry away in fear from the wrath of my patronus piggy!

  10. Jen says:

    I won’t share my patronus ideas here because they are going to be part of my post friday, but look out for more patronus-related discussions. Ewan McGregor as Lupin? That’s so hot. I can’t remember how I pictured him. Younger and more handsome than he was portrayed in the movies, that’s for sure.


Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: